Daily Beirut

World

Winners Without a Deal, Losers Without a Seat: The Harvest of the Trump-Xi-Putin Summit

Analysis of the trilateral summit between US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of APEC in Shenzhen. Experts weigh the diplomatic gains for Beijing and Moscow against the marginalization of Ukraine, Europe, and the ICC.

··4 min read
Winners Without a Deal, Losers Without a Seat: The Harvest of the Trump-Xi-Putin Summit
Share

The world's eyes turned today to the trilateral summit that brought together the leaders of the United States, Russia, and China amid questions about its outcomes.

Before their trilateral meeting on the sidelines of the "APEC" summit in the Chinese city of Shenzhen, US President Donald Trump and his counterparts, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, indicated that they were determining the fate of the world.

Following a 90-minute meeting, the three leaders issued a statement that will be scrutinized to identify which issues received priority, what was excluded, and who emerged as winners and losers, according to the American magazine "Newsweek."

One party emerged from this encounter in a stronger position. William Yang, Senior Analyst specializing in Northeast Asia at the "International Crisis Group," told "Newsweek" magazine on Thursday.

Winners
China
William Yang, Senior Analyst specializing in Northeast Asia at the "International Crisis Group," believes that the joint statement, which included thanks from Putin and Trump to President Xi for hosting the summit, indicates an effort by the Russian and American leaders to win over their Chinese counterpart.

He said: "On the other hand, China succeeded in avoiding commitment to trilateral nuclear negotiations, something it considers unfair to its interests and position."

Given that the meeting yielded no tangible results regarding the settlement of the war in Ukraine, China also avoided any tension in its relations with European countries by hosting this summit.

Yang added: "Overall, Beijing will feel more confident about its relative standing compared to both Washington and Moscow following this meeting."

Putin
After years of isolation and sanctions imposed on Russia due to the war in Ukraine, Putin's presence at the table of major global diplomacy was welcomed by Russian media.

Trump's statements regarding the International Criminal Court and the declared stance against it will benefit the Russian leader, as will the discourse presented during the summit, which reinforces his vision of a world order shifting away from Western dominance.

During his farewell to Xi, Putin said that the meeting with his Chinese host: "went better than anyone expected," adding: "No one expected things to go this well."

Losers
Ukraine and Europe
Trump mentioned that he discussed the wars in Iran and Ukraine with Putin and Xi, but these files were not mentioned in the statement issued by Russia and China.

While expectations were tempered beforehand regarding any breakthrough concerning the war in Ukraine, the absence of any immediate public commitment from Putin to end the war will raise concern in both Kyiv and Europe.

Europe bears the consequences of the war in Ukraine, and although it is not a member of "APEC," this meeting highlights how the European continent is being marginalized by Trump in his efforts to negotiate an end to the war.

The trilateral summit may have granted legitimacy to Russia's refusal of European efforts aimed at reaching the negotiating table.

In this context, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk posted a message on the platform "X" reflecting a sense of sorrow, writing, "God help us from such friends."

The International Criminal Court
The International Criminal Court was a focal point of criticism, both in the joint statement and in the remarks made by Trump before the three leaders held a closed-door meeting.

At the start of the meeting, Trump said the court had "gone rogue"; a statement that will find positive resonance with Putin, who was issued an international arrest warrant in 2023 on charges related to the abduction of Ukrainian children.

The phrase in the statement affirming that "respecting the immunity of state officials is crucial" can also be seen as a pledge to support Putin in the face of accusations of war crimes.

Nuclear Weapons
Before the summit, the White House stated that the leaders might discuss establishing rules for nuclear arms control. Trump's remarks prior to the meeting that these countries are in a "unique position to discuss ways to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth" indicate the importance of this issue as a legacy he seeks to leave during his presidency.

After the "New START" treaty, which regulates the nuclear arsenals of both Russia and the United States, expired last February, Trump expressed his desire to conclude a new agreement that includes China.

Beijing remains cautious about imposing restrictions on its nuclear arsenal; therefore, the joint statement issued on Thursday was met with cautious optimism after stating that the three countries would enter into dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.

In a statement to "Newsweek," Daryl G. Kimball, Executive Director of the "Arms Control Association," said it is "positive that the leaders of the three largest nuclear arsenals reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, and expressed their willingness to continue dialogue on nuclear non-proliferation."

But Kimball noted that to achieve concrete progress, the leaders must "task their senior diplomats and experts with developing and discussing balanced proposals aimed at capping and reducing deadly nuclear arsenals, while being prepared to engage in give-and-take negotiations that lead to real results."

Al-Ain News

Add Daily Beirut to your Google News feed to get the latest first.
Share