Russia and Israel Oppose UN Human Rights Chief Volker Turk's Second Term

Volker Turk, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, is encountering resistance from Russia and Israel regarding his potential second four-year term, with a contentious vote scheduled for Friday.

Turk is recognized for his outspoken criticism of Russia's war in Ukraine and Israel's actions in Gaza, according to Reuters.

His current term is set to expire in October. Turk, an Austrian lawyer, has served the UN for decades in key offices such as Geneva and field locations including Kosovo.

UN Secretary-General António Guterres has nominated Turk for another term extending until October 2030. The two have collaborated closely in the past.

Guterres’ own term concludes in December; however, Russia has proposed an alternative to extend Guterres’ tenure by just over two months, until the end of the current year.

Three diplomats reported that Israel also opposes Turk’s four-year extension, while Washington has expressed reservations, turning what was expected to be a consensual renewal into a divisive vote.

Others in private discussions have questioned the idea of granting Turk a full additional term, suggesting that the decision should be made by Guterres’ successor. One diplomat stated, "It is up to the next Secretary-General."

The Russian mission to the United Nations in New York commented that reappointing Turk for four years would deprive the new Secretary-General of the opportunity to select a candidate for this important post for an extended period.

They described the proposal as arbitrary, considering the sensitivity of the human rights structure and its role within the UN overall.

The mission added that many UN member states share this viewpoint and said, "Tomorrow we will see how many are prepared to openly declare their position without fear of repercussions."

Since the vote will take place in the UN General Assembly, the veto power held by Russia and other permanent Security Council members—China, the United States, the United Kingdom, and France—does not apply in this case.

When asked earlier in the week about Turk’s reappointment, Thameen Al-Khitan, spokesperson for Turk’s office, declined to comment and said, "I believe the High Commissioner is ready to serve."

The High Commissioner position, established in 1993, plays a critical role in condemning the erosion of freedoms at a time when authoritarian regimes are gaining influence at the expense of democracy.

Some early critics of Turk’s appointment had expected him to adopt a more restrained approach. Contrary to that, he has repeatedly criticized governments including those of Russia, Israel, and the United States.